Government rejects pesticide science

September 10, 2013
By

honey beeScientific disputes continue over the impacts of neonicotinoid chemicals on bees

The government says it accepts the EU ban on the use of some pesticides linked to bee deaths, but it rejects the science behind the moratorium.

In a response to the Environmental Audit Committee, the government indicates it will not ban the use of these chemicals for gardeners.

The Committee says they are disappointed with this approach.

But the National Farmers Union says the government view is “balanced and sensible”.

Last April, the European Commission agreed to a EU wide ban for two years from December on some neonicotinoid chemicals, used on crops attractive to bees.

Continue reading the main story

Start Quote

There is no justification for people using these products on their Dahlias when they could be damaging pollinator populations”

End Quote
Joan Whalley, MP
Environmental Audit Committee

While there has been scientific division on the impact of these pesticides on bees, the British government strongly opposed the plans.

The House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee (EAC) criticized the government’s approach in their report earlier this year.

The government now says that they accept the ban but not the science behind it.

“We opposed these restrictions because our assessment was (and remains) that the evidence did not point to risks to pollinators that would justify the proposed restrictions,” they wrote in a response that has been published by the Committee.

The government stated they were not convinced by the results of laboratory studies showing harmful effects to bees from these chemicals. They argue that an “increasing number of field-realistic studies have failed to find an effect of neonicotinoids on bees.”

They also rejected the idea of banning the sale of neonicotinoids for use by gardeners and in parks.

However the chair of the EAC, Joan Walley, MP says she is not happy with the government’s ongoing wrangling over the science.

“I am disappointed that the government has not accepted the great weight of scientific evidence that points to the need for the ban on these pesticides in line with the precautionary principle,” she said.

“There is no justification for people using these products on their Dahlias when they could be damaging pollinator populations.”

beesThe government says that the sale of neonicotinoid chemicals to amateur gardeners should continue

However the National Farmer’s Union welcomed the government’s response to the Committee. Dr Chris Hartfield said it was a balanced and sensible assessment of the science.

“While acknowledging the importance of pollinators, the government’s response also importantly recognizes the value to society of food production and the underpinning role pesticides play in that production,” he said.

“These benefits have to be part of the consideration when managing the risks posed to the environment by pesticides.”

Both Syngenta and Bayer, which manufacture the chemicals at the center of the moratorium, are now taking legal action against the European Commission in an effort to overturn the ban.

Follow Matt on Twitter.

Deeter Does Wirless

Article source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-24024634#sa-ns_mchannel=rss&ns_source=PublicRSS20-sa The feed :

Tags:

Sponsored By:

The Deeter Group

Deeter Electronics Ltd. | Deeter Electronics Inc | Deeter Group Asia | Deeter Group Germany | Deeter Group Corporate

Head & Registered Office:
Deeter Electronics Ltd.
Deeter House,
Valley Road,
Hughenden Valley,
Bucks. HP14 4LW

Tel: +44 (0) 1494 566 046
Fax: +44 (0) 1494 563 961
E-mail: [email protected]


The Deeter Group with products ranging from: , , , continuous , 4-20mA , , , , , , , a , wireless sensor and much more.

If you want a standard or a custom level switch, float switch, level sensor, or wireless sensor, contact us via email [email protected] or call us now on 01494 566 046.

Company Name: The Deeter Group

Location: Hughenden Valley, UK

Deeter Electronics USA
Deeter Electronics USA
Wireless sensor system | Radio telemetry | Level switches | Level sensors | Liquid level sensor | Float switches | Controllers & indicators | Industrial weighing equipment | Electronic circuit design & manufacture | Software design | Reed relays | Ultrasonic level flow sludge & proximity sensors | Proximity sensors & switches | Reed switches | Litz wire | Wago Terminals | Mechanical & magnetic floats | Boiler control |

Deeter Electronics UK
Wireless sensor system | Radio telemetry | Level switches | Level sensors | Liquid level sensor | Float switches | Controllers & indicators | Industrial weighing equipment | Electronic circuit design & manufacture | Software design | Reed relays | Ultrasonic level flow sludge & proximity sensors | Proximity sensors & switches | Reed switches | Litz wire | Wago Terminals | Mechanical & magnetic floats | Boiler control |

Deeter Electronics Europe
Wireless sensor system | Radio telemetry | Level switches | Level sensors | Liquid level sensor | Float switches | Controllers & indicators | Industrial weighing equipment | Electronic circuit design & manufacture | Software design | Ultrasonic level flow sludge & proximity sensors | Proximity sensors & switches | Reed switches | Litz wire | Wago Terminals | Mechanical & magnetic floats | Boiler control |

Sensor Magazine Websites
Explosion Proof Sensors UK | Explosion Proof Sensors | Water Level Measurement | Liquid Level Sensing | Liquid Level Measurement | Liquid Level Sensors UK | Liquid Level Sensors Europe | Wireless Sensors | Sensor Magazine | Industrial Sensors



Water use